Fan re-edits The Hobbit single, reasonable movie

“Sara writes, “It has been a few years since The Hobbit has its theatrical release and some fans have been toiling since then on the perfect edit. Joblit has posted links to his latest version… ” – My Comments : Jobilt actually came up with three different edits, a “preferred Theatrical Edition (2:42), a richer Extended Edition (3:45), and a brisk Ludicrous Edition (2:10).”

I only watched the first one and was fairly disappointed in comparison to the excellent adaptations of the LotR films. As a big Tolkien fan, though, I almost feel as if I should watch the other two instead of one these edits, though. Thoughts?